Saturday, 21 July 2012

A Clash of Kings, George R. R. Martin

Contain spoilers

Apologies for the long delay in writing. I had planned to write this review in two parts, but while drafting it, I got caught up in a rant about the treatment of women in A Song of Ice and Fire, and got stuck. By the time I'd worked out what I really wanted to say, I'd finished reading the book, so sorry for the long post. (Now I've cooled down I've removed the rant, but be warned, it could make a reappearance.)


The story so far


The King is dead - long live the King! But would that be King Joffrey, teenaged son of the old King, Robert Baratheon - or at least, son of Robert's wife? Or King Stannis, or King Renly, Robert's brothers? Or Robb Stark, son of the late Eddard and now setting himself up as King in the North? One thing is certain: there will be no easy resolution to the conflict, and victory will come at a high cost.

A Clash of Kings picks up where A Game of Thrones left off, with the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros split into factions all at war with each other - sometimes forming temporary alliances, more often just putting their enemies in order of who to destroy first, and who next. A Song of Ice and Fire isn't necessarily eight different stories about eight different sets of people whose paths cross every so often: It's one multi-dimensioned epic, and each person's point-of-view chapters bring something different to the story. Jon Snow's chapters, set outside the Seven Kingdoms bring an atmosphere of dread and foreboding, a wildness that's kept out only by a great wall. Catelyn Stark exposes the idiocy of the entire war: a few men (and a couple of women) who would sacrifice their entire nation to the god of their pride. The children's chapters portray a world where there is no place for innocence. I spent the whole of A Game of Thrones feeling impatient with  Sansa for having a naive romanticised view of the world - then I stopped and thought, she's eleven! She's supposed to be innocent and idealistic. But all too soon, she was forced to grow up and survive on her cunning, while her younger sister Arya is living by her wits and her sword, out in the wild. Meanwhile, Tyrion Lannister's chapters provide a snarky commentary to the follies of the Lannister dynasty, and injects some much-needed humour and decency into a bleak setting. Tyrion is probably my favourite character in the saga: he is loyal to his family, for all their faults (and "faults" is a nice way of putting it) but he does his best to keep them in check, especially the awful teenaged king Joffrey and his scheming mother Cersei.

With so much taking place within this story, spread all across the continent of Westeros, it starts quite slowly,
bringing the reader up to speed with what's happening to whom and where, as well as introducing a couple of new characters. Each chapter is told from the point of view of a different character, in a different place, which means that it sometimes took me a moment to remind myself where I'd left them. Martin would leave a chapter on a cliffhanger, then send the story across the country so that by the time something major happened, I'd forgotten about it, and it came as more of a shock, as if out of the blue. (No doubt this was deliberate on Martin's part, the sly dog!) Also, the story continues off the page while other characters are having their moment in the spotlight. Sometimes we don't hear of a major event until after it's happened, and from a third party. I'll admit it, he tricked me good and proper at one point.

Theon Greyjoy, in particular, has much of his story unshown. Introduced in A Game of Thrones as a shifty-looking extra who lived with the Stark family at Winterfell, now he gets his own point-of-view chapters, which reveal him to be a nasty piece of work indeed, if something of an enigma.

As well as the Stark family, on whom the majority of A Game of Thrones was focused, some new characters are introduced: The smuggler-turned-lord Davos (and I keep wanting to take one of George Martin's "R"s and stick it in him...) who serves as the viewpoint for Stannis Baratheon's household and army. We'd only heard of Stannis in passing in A Game of Thrones, and I had a clear image of him in my mind. Stannis was Ned Stark's choice for king, and so I imagined him as someone from the same mould of honour and uprightness, if humourless. Instead we are shown a proud, angry, bitter man who has taken up with the mysterious Red Woman, Melisande, a practitioner of dark arts and generally rather scary lady. There is more magic in this book than the last: more is made of Bran Stark's psychic dreams, and it emerges that he and his siblings have the same mental bond with their pet direwolves. From early on in A Game of Thrones, both I and my friend, who is reading alone with me, independently were reminded of the daemons in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials. This likeness has only strengthened as the books have continued.

A Game of Thrones ended with Daenerys, an exiled claimant to the throne having hatched three baby dragons from her husband's funeral pyre - a dramatic end of a book indeed! But in this book, I thought that the practicalities of having three living mascots around her at all times was a little bit ridiculous, and her calling them her children made me think of a mad cat lady.

Daenerys: But look! I have dragons! Marvel at my dragons!
Me: Yes, but what are you going to do with them? One does not simply keep dragons as pets. Have you any idea how to train them for battle? If you go to King's Landing with them, you'll end up Queen of a pile of smoking ruins if you're not careful. 
Daenerys: ... I have dragons!


Though I enjoyed seeing her develop from a timid girl to a wife to a queen and "mother of dragons" in the first book, here she spends her time wandering from deserted desert city to deserted desert city, seeking a ship to take her and her army to Westeros to reclaim the Iron throne. It was quite slow going, although there was an impressive scene where she walks through "The House of the Undying" (which in my mind looks a lot like my imagining of the Department of Mysteries in Harry Potter, just in an ancient desert city) and is shown strange visions and told prophecies that I'm sure will be explained as the events of the next three books unfold. There will be three fires: one of life, one of death, one of love - all of these could refer to Khal Drogo's pyre at the end of A Game of Thrones, which brought life to the dragons, death to the maegi Mirri Maz Duur, and was the pyre of her lover and husband Khal Drogo. But what about the treasons: one of blood, one of gold, one of love? I guess I'll just have to wait and see.

Although slow to begin with (which is not the same as dull) I sped through the last hundred and fifty pages or so of A Clash of Kings, which wrought all kinds of triumphs and devastations across Westeros. Winterfell is a smoking ruin, overthrown first by Theon Greyjoy, who was betrayed in turn, and whether or not he even lives is not made clear. The two youngest Stark boys do live, but are believed dead, and separated, on their way to who knows where. Their tomboyish sister Arya, too, is on the run.

Sansa Stark does not have to marry the ghastly King Joffrey - but I am hesitant to rejoice about this, because I'm pretty sure that Martin only gives his characters good news to make their next bad news hit twice as hard.

Jon Snow, north of the Wall, has surrendered to the "wildlings" who live in the wilderness, on his superior's orders, to spy for the Night's Watch - and I think that the wildling girl, Ygritte, who he had previously taken captive, but released, will be a significant character later on. And Daenerys has found ships at last, and two new companions, and is ready to embark on a voyage to Westeros, to join in the fight for the Iron Throne.

We haven't seen much of Robb Stark in this book, although we've heard that he's been fighting and winning battles - but there were not too many battle scenes, to my relief. The only battle scene of any significance was the siege of King's Landing, which is remarkable for being a sea battle. Though I found the chapter hard to get into at first, with far too many details about the many ships in the fleet, it became something thrilling and terrifying once the magical Wildfire made an appearance. (I still think that if that Wildfire is used again, it will cost the users more than it gains them. It's a nasty substance, engineered by alchemists, and I can only see it ending in a disaster.) In the battle for King's Landing, Tyrion Lannister was seriously wounded - probably as an attempted murder by his sister Cersei, who resented his influence over Joffrey and the King's council, and meddling in her evil plotting.

But there are remarkably few battle sequences for what is, after all, a war epic. Instead, the focus is on the politics: the intrigues and tactics and alliances and treacheries, and the high and lowly people involved. This sounds deadly dull and put me off reading the series for a long time, but in fact it's clever stuff indeed. Clever enough to mastermind one side in such a multi-sided war, but when I think that all this came from the mind of one man, it is staggering!

Even so, perhaps it was a mistake to read a high fantasy epic that takes itself fairly seriously immediately after a Terry Pratchett novel or two, because I could not keep from laughing in a couple of places, when Martin wrote tropes into his story that Pratchett has satirised and deconstructed. When Arya Stark disguised herself as a boy, all I could think of was I hope you have a spare pair of socks. And then, on page 47, I couldn't believe my eyes:
'One peddlar was hawking rats roasted on a skewer. "Fresh rats," he cried loudly. "Fresh rats." '
("Onna stick!" interrupted his companion, a man who looked as rodent-like as the wares he was selling. "Ketchup ten pence extra!")


I have absolutely no idea what to expect from the rest of this series. No idea whatsoever. And that's really exciting.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Come and say hello! I don't bite (well, except at the full moon...)

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...